Amazon FBA vs. Dropshipping: Who’s Really Winning the Ecommerce Battle?
In the exciting and ever-changing world of ecommerce, two business models have been fighting for the spotlight: dropshipping and Amazon FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon). Both have their own advantages, but many people are realizing that Amazon FBA sellers often come out on top. Why? Amazon FBA gives sellers more control, powerful tools, and the ability to scale quickly, while dropshippers have to work extra hard to make a profit.
Let’s dive into a real-life example that shows why Amazon FBA might just be the winning strategy—and how one product, in particular, helped an FBA seller rake in $40,000 a month!
Dropshipping: Chasing Trends, But What’s the Catch?
Dropshipping is popular for good reasons. It’s one of the easiest ways to start an online business. You don’t need to buy inventory upfront or handle shipping. You act as the middleman—customers buy from you, and your supplier ships directly to them. It’s low-risk, and all you really need is a laptop and good marketing skills.
But here’s where things get tough. Dropshippers live and die by trends. They need to constantly find new trending products, create viral ads, and stay ahead of the competition. And once the trend is over, so are the sales. Not to mention, dropshippers often face long shipping times and inconsistent product quality, which can lead to unhappy customers.
In short, dropshipping can feel like running on a hamster wheel—you’re always chasing the next big thing but rarely build a long-lasting brand.
Amazon FBA: Let Amazon Do the Heavy Lifting
Now, let’s talk about Amazon FBA. Unlike dropshipping, Amazon FBA sellers send their products to Amazon’s warehouses, and Amazon handles the rest—storage, shipping, and even customer service. This frees up a lot of time for sellers to focus on other parts of the business, like marketing or finding new products
FBA sellers also benefit from Amazon’s Prime program. Most people love getting their products fast, and with Prime, Amazon FBA sellers can offer two-day shipping, which dropshippers just can’t compete with. Plus, being a Prime seller can boost your product’s visibility and sales.
But the real secret weapon for Amazon FBA sellers is the data and tools available to them. Tools like Jungle Scout allow sellers to analyze the market, find profitable products, and avoid saturated markets. This is a huge advantage that dropshippers don’t always have access to.
Let’s look at a real example to see how one Amazon FBA seller outsmarted the competition and made serious profits.
Case Study: How Car LED Matrix Made $40,000 a Month
So, here’s what happened. I was scrolling through Amazon India and came across a product called Car LED Matrix. When I searched for it, I found only one relevant listing, surrounded by a bunch of unrelated products. It wasn’t exactly what I expected, so I decided to dig deeper using Jungle Scout to see if this product was worth selling on Amazon.
Here’s what I found:
On Amazon India, the Car LED Matrix had low demand and low competition. It wasn’t doing much, and I wasn’t sure if it was a good opportunity. But then, I checked Amazon.com (the U.S. market), and the story was completely different. The product had high demand and low competition—a dream scenario for any Amazon FBA seller. And here’s the kicker: one seller was making around $40,000 a month, selling about 1,300 units of this product every single month!
Why Amazon FBA Sellers Outshine Dropshippers
This case study perfectly highlights the differences between dropshipping and Amazon FBA. Dropshippers work hard to create demand for products, running Facebook and Instagram ads to get people’s attention. But once a product gains traction, it’s not uncommon for Amazon FBA sellers to swoop in and steal the show—using tools, data, and Amazon’s huge platform to dominate the market.
Here’s why Amazon FBA sellers often outshine dropshippers:
Data is King: Amazon FBA sellers use tools like Jungle Scout to find hidden opportunities—products with high demand and low competition. Dropshippers, on the other hand, often rely on guesswork and social media trends, which can be hit or miss.
Better Customer Experience: FBA sellers control their inventory, ensuring fast delivery (thanks to Amazon Prime) and consistent quality. Dropshippers, on the other hand, have to rely on suppliers, who may be slow to ship and inconsistent with product quality, leading to customer dissatisfaction.
Building a Brand: Amazon FBA allows you to build a real brand. By creating a strong product listing, gathering reviews, and offering great customer service, FBA sellers can build a long-term, sustainable business. Dropshipping, in contrast, often focuses on quick wins with trending products that don’t last.
Higher Profit Margins: While dropshippers make money from selling trending products, their margins are usually slim due to competition and heavy advertising costs. FBA sellers, with the right product, can sell at a higher price and enjoy bigger margins.
Scalability: Once an Amazon FBA seller finds a winning product, they can easily scale their business. Amazon takes care of everything from storage to shipping, allowing sellers to focus on growing. Dropshippers, on the other hand, may struggle to keep up if their supplier can’t meet demand or if a product trend fades.
So, What’s the Verdict?
While dropshipping can be a great way to get started in ecommerce, Amazon FBA offers more long-term potential. The Car LED Matrix example shows just how powerful the right product, backed by data and smart strategies, can be for FBA sellers. Tools like Jungle Scout give Amazon sellers a clear edge, allowing them to find high-demand, low-competition products that can bring in substantial revenue.
But that doesn’t mean dropshipping is dead. Dropshipping still works, especially if you’re quick at finding new trends and marketing them. However, if you’re serious about building a sustainable business that can grow over time, Amazon FBA might just be the better choice.
Are You Team Dropshipping or Team Amazon FBA?
Now, I want to hear from you! Are you currently dropshipping or using Amazon FBA? Which model do you think is more effective for building a successful business? Let me know in the comments below.
And if you enjoyed this blog or found it helpful, make sure to share it with your fellow entrepreneurs who are looking to make their mark in the world of ecommerce!
Cheers to your success!
Join Our Webinar: "How to Sell Popular Brands on Amazon"
To further enhance your Amazon FBA journey, we invite you to join our exclusive webinar on "How to Sell Popular Brands on Amazon." This webinar is designed to provide you with in-depth knowledge and practical tips on:
- Identifying and sourcing popular brands
- Negotiating with brand owners and distributors
- Creating compelling listings and optimizing for conversions
- Implementing advanced marketing strategies to boost sales
Why Attend Our Webinar?
- Expert Insights: Learn from experienced Amazon FBA sellers who have successfully built and scaled their businesses.
- Actionable Strategies: Get step-by-step guidance on how to sell popular brands and stand out in the competitive Amazon marketplace.
- Q&A Session: Have your questions answered by experts during the live Q&A session.
- Exclusive Resources: Access valuable resources, templates, and checklists to kickstart your journey.
Get access to a live webinar on Amazon FBA
from our e-commerce expert
Mr. Amar Bedi
About the Author:-
Amar Bedi initiated his E-commerce venture 7 years back after receiving 6 months of comprehensive training in New York, New Jersey, and Los Angeles (LA). During this time, he gained valuable insights into the operations of E-commerce businesses centered around Amazon, working with top-tier companies.
He possesses over 16 years of industry experience, including 8 years of national and international E-commerce exposure. In 2015, he successfully relocated their E-commerce operations to India. Throughout his E-commerce journey, he has successfully facilitated over $70 million (Rs 500 Cr+) in domestic and international sales through the Amazon platform for his clients and his company. He has collaborated with prominent international brands and established partnerships with leading brands in India. Now, after accumulating 8 years of extensive E-commerce expertise, he is eager to share his journey and give back to the community.
